The Supreme Court on Tuesday reserved its verdict on the sentence to be imposed on advocate Prashant Bhushan in the contempt case filed against him for his tweets criticising the judiciary, legal news website BarandBench.com reported.
The order was reserved by a Bench of Justices Arun Mishra, BR Gavai and Krishna Murari, who heard Senior Advocate Rajeev Dhavan and Attorney General for India KK Venugopal at length.
Dhavan, appearing for Bhushan, informed the court that his client had submitted a statement clarifying his stance yesterday.Bhushan had filed a supplementary statement reiterating his position to stand by his tweets. He refused to apologise for the tweets for which he was held to be in contempt for. His statement says, "If I retract a statement before this court that I otherwise believe to be true or offer an insincere apology, that in my eyes would amount to the contempt of my conscience and of an institution that I hold in highest esteem."
The court then sought the views of Attorney General KK Venugopal on how to proceed with the matter. The AG responded, "He (Bhushan) may be given a warning first and let go. He need not be punished."Justice Mishra then said, "But he doesn't think whatever he did was wrong. He did not submit an apology...What to do when someone does not think they did something wrong?"
The AG then reminded the Bench of the time he had proceeded against Bhushan in connection with the Rafale case."He (Bhushan) expressed regret and then when I read it, I thought we should not proceed with contempt and I withdrew the same because he expressed regret...it will be a great service if Your Lordships take a compassionate view and leave it there," he said.
Justice Mishra went on to say, "When Mr. Bhushan does not think he did anything wrong then what is the point of giving him advice to not repeat it?"
When the AG pointed out the good work Bhushan has done by filing PILs before the Court, Justice Gavai remarked, "PILs and all is good work but when it came to you, even you filed a contempt......You withdrew it only after he expressed regret. But that's not the case here."
Justice Mishra added, "There are very serious statements made. They are asking us to consider his defence during sentencing...He has made so many remarks. Even in the Ramjanmabhoomi case...Only one of those judges has retired."
When Venugopal said that Bhushan would not do it again, the court replied, "Let him say that. But he then instead of that he gave colour to those tweets."
Venugopal then suggested that Bhushan's response be taken off record. However, Justice Mishra said, "Everyone is criticizing us that we have not considered his response and the AG is saying take his response off the record... Now if this is removed, we will be blamed that we removed his response on our own."
The Bench went on to refer to a statement made by Bhushan saying that the "Supreme Court has collapsed"."Isn't that objectionable?" asked Justice Mishra.Referring to the various allegations made by Bhushan in his filings, Justice Mishra said, "Which judge is left out, sitting or retired?" The Court then broke for lunch.
PM on his side, BJP nominee claims edge …
16-05-2024
BJP's Anurag Sharma in Jhansi faces challenge from INDIA bloc's Pradeep Jain Aditya. Sharma, backed by PM Narendra Modi's popularity, confident due to party's micromanagement of elections. He criticizes INID...
Read more‘INDIA bloc strong, inter-party support …
16-05-2024
Tanuj Punia, INDIA bloc candidate from Barabanki, prioritizes survival over the Ram Temple. In an interview with TOI, he contrasts his corporate background with politics, highlighting accountability differences. Despite past...
Read moreLok Sabha polls: Ken-Betwa link, stateho…
16-05-2024
Water crisis in Bundelkhand region emphasized in political rallies, discussions on Ken-Betwa riverlinking project, Modi government's involvement, benefits for Bundelkhand region of MP and UP, concerns raised by farmers like...
Read moreIn Bundelkhand, BJP banks on ration …
16-05-2024
Bundelkhand region in UP, including Jhansi, sees improvements with projects like Har Ghar Nal, defense corridor, and BIDA. Political dynamics involve BJP, SP-Congress alliance, and issues like unemployment and development...
Read moreAs Sena faces Sena, Nashik battle hinges…
16-05-2024
Maharashtra deputy chief minister Ajit Pawar's close aide Chhagan Bhujbal faced delays in being announced as the candidate for Nashik. CM Eknath Shinde's push for a candidate of his choice...
Read moreBJP's CAA card has confused Matua voters…
16-05-2024
Bongaon, a critical Lok Sabha constituency on the India-Bangladesh border, witnesses a quiet period before polling. The Matua community, dominant with 70% of voters, is central. Concerns about CAA-NRC, lack...
Read moreNo writ petition can be filed against Ai…
16-05-2024
Supreme Court rules writ petitions by erstwhile employees against Air India post privatization by Tata group in Jan 2022 are not maintainable as it ceased to be a public body...
Read moreLand acquisition valid only if it passes…
16-05-2024
Supreme Court's ruling enforces Article 300A, protecting landowners' rights. It specifies seven procedural rights and duties, including fair compensation and efficient acquisition conduct. The court also quashed Kolkata Municipal Corporation's...
Read moreTurnout in 1st 4 phases of Lok Sabha pol…
16-05-2024
Voter turnout in Lok Sabha polls is at 67%, with 45.1 crore of 97 crore electors voting. Polling data show a dip in turnout in first three phases compared to...
Read moreNo exception made for CM Arvind Kejriwal…
16-05-2024
The Supreme Court rejected Arvind Kejriwal's plea challenging his arrest, emphasizing judicial restraint and fair decision-making by ED officers. The hearing involved arguments by Solicitor General Tushar Mehta and senior...
Read moreMonsoon to arrive on time in Maharashtra…
16-05-2024
IMD announced a near-normal monsoon onset over Kerala, indicating timely rains over parts of south peninsular India, Northeast, and Maharashtra. Top weather experts supported the favorable scenario for the monsoon...
Read more'Can't allow misuse of court to kill unw…
16-05-2024
The Madhya Pradesh high court has declined to allow medical termination of pregnancy for a juvenile girl who was allegedly raped by her brother-in-law, after she and her mother testified...
Read moreDon't do pressers as media not neutral, …
16-05-2024
PM Modi defends media stance, criticizes past leaders for compromising Election Commission's independence. Points to historical instances of Constitution tampering by Nehru, Indira, Rajiv Gandhi, and Rahul Gandhi, highlighting media...
Read moreIn 3rd term, NDA will ban cow slaughter…
16-05-2024
Amit Shah pledges to ban cow slaughter and 'straighten' offenders, targeting Congress, Lalu Prasad, and PFI. Vows to build a grand temple at Punaura Dham, birthplace of Sita, in Bihar...
Read moreED can't arrest accused once court takes…
16-05-2024
Supreme Court restricts ED's arrest power under PMLA post special court's cognisance. Justices A S Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan emphasize Section 4 of PMLA, Article 21 rights, and accused treatment...
Read moreEx-IAS officer acquitted in rape case af…
16-05-2024
Former IAS officer B B Mohanty acquitted of rape charges in Jaipur court after 10 years. The special metropolitan court for Pocso cases agreed with the defence that the complainant...
Read morePump ran for 2 years sans OC, BMC still …
16-05-2024
A petrol pump in Mumbai crashed due to operating without an OC. BMC is investigating the lack of a letter of approval, legal department's involvement, and statements from Bhushan Gagrani.
Read more