The Supreme Court on Tuesday reserved its verdict on the sentence to be imposed on advocate Prashant Bhushan in the contempt case filed against him for his tweets criticising the judiciary, legal news website BarandBench.com reported.
The order was reserved by a Bench of Justices Arun Mishra, BR Gavai and Krishna Murari, who heard Senior Advocate Rajeev Dhavan and Attorney General for India KK Venugopal at length.
Dhavan, appearing for Bhushan, informed the court that his client had submitted a statement clarifying his stance yesterday.Bhushan had filed a supplementary statement reiterating his position to stand by his tweets. He refused to apologise for the tweets for which he was held to be in contempt for. His statement says, "If I retract a statement before this court that I otherwise believe to be true or offer an insincere apology, that in my eyes would amount to the contempt of my conscience and of an institution that I hold in highest esteem."
The court then sought the views of Attorney General KK Venugopal on how to proceed with the matter. The AG responded, "He (Bhushan) may be given a warning first and let go. He need not be punished."Justice Mishra then said, "But he doesn't think whatever he did was wrong. He did not submit an apology...What to do when someone does not think they did something wrong?"
The AG then reminded the Bench of the time he had proceeded against Bhushan in connection with the Rafale case."He (Bhushan) expressed regret and then when I read it, I thought we should not proceed with contempt and I withdrew the same because he expressed regret...it will be a great service if Your Lordships take a compassionate view and leave it there," he said.
Justice Mishra went on to say, "When Mr. Bhushan does not think he did anything wrong then what is the point of giving him advice to not repeat it?"
When the AG pointed out the good work Bhushan has done by filing PILs before the Court, Justice Gavai remarked, "PILs and all is good work but when it came to you, even you filed a contempt......You withdrew it only after he expressed regret. But that's not the case here."
Justice Mishra added, "There are very serious statements made. They are asking us to consider his defence during sentencing...He has made so many remarks. Even in the Ramjanmabhoomi case...Only one of those judges has retired."
When Venugopal said that Bhushan would not do it again, the court replied, "Let him say that. But he then instead of that he gave colour to those tweets."
Venugopal then suggested that Bhushan's response be taken off record. However, Justice Mishra said, "Everyone is criticizing us that we have not considered his response and the AG is saying take his response off the record... Now if this is removed, we will be blamed that we removed his response on our own."
The Bench went on to refer to a statement made by Bhushan saying that the "Supreme Court has collapsed"."Isn't that objectionable?" asked Justice Mishra.Referring to the various allegations made by Bhushan in his filings, Justice Mishra said, "Which judge is left out, sitting or retired?" The Court then broke for lunch.
VP Jagdeep Dhankhar criticises 'weaponiz…
22-01-2025
Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar raised concerns over the misuse of judicial access, calling it a threat to India's governance and democracy. He criticized institutions for overstepping their jurisdiction and questioned...
Read moreStudents learn about water conservation …
22-01-2025
At the Mahakumbh, the Jal Jeevan Mission's exhibition highlights the transformation in Uttar Pradesh villages through the 'Har Ghar Nal' project. Students from Prayagraj learned about its impact on water-scarce...
Read moreShiv Sena's Sanjay Nirupam questions Sai…
22-01-2025
Shiv Sena leader Sanjay Nirupam questions Saif Ali Khan's rapid recovery after a six-hour surgery, while Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut calls it a medical miracle. The Bollywood actor...
Read moreJalgaon train accident: At least 12 pers…
22-01-2025
Several people were killed in Maharashtra's Jalgaon district when they stepped onto tracks due to a fire rumour and were struck by another train. The incident near Pachora station involved...
Read moreWatch: Car falls from first-floor parkin…
22-01-2025
A car accidentally reversed off the first-floor parking of Shubh Gateway Apartment in Pune, crashing to the ground and causing shock among onlookers. The incident, captured on CCTV, has raised...
Read moreProtests against BPSC exam escalate as e…
22-01-2025
Protests over the controversial 70th BPSC exam intensified as educator Guru Rahman attempted self-harm. Rahman joined students in demanding a re-examination, alleging a paper leak. Despite the BPSC's denial of...
Read moreIsro satellite captures Maha Kumbh 2025 …
22-01-2025
ISRO's EOS-04 satellite captured detailed images of the ongoing Maha Kumbh Mela 2025 in Prayagraj. The images reveal extensive infrastructure like tent cities and pontoon bridges. Using radar technology to...
Read moreCBI to move Calcutta high court seeking …
22-01-2025
The Central Bureau of Investigation plans to seek the death penalty for Sanjay Roy in the Calcutta high court, following the West Bengal government’s similar appeal. Roy was sentenced to...
Read moreSkincare brand Deconstruct bags Rs 65 cr…
22-01-2025
Deconstruct, a skincare brand, has secured Rs 65 crore in funding from investors including L’Oréal's BOLD, V3 Ventures, DSG Consumer Partners, Kalaari Capital, and Beenext. The funds will enhance product...
Read moreR G Kar rape-murder case: Supreme Court …
22-01-2025
The Supreme Court postponed the suo motu case on the safety of medical professionals following the RG Kar Medical College rape and murder to January 29. West Bengal is seeking...
Read more'He acted on his own': JD(U) sacks Manip…
22-01-2025
The Janata Dal (United) formally withdrew support from the BJP-led Manipur government, directing their lone MLA, Md Abdul Nasir, to join the opposition. JD(U) had initially aligned with the INDIA...
Read moreDelhi poll campaign: SC delivers split v…
22-01-2025
The Supreme Court delivered a split verdict on Tahir Hussain's plea for interim bail to campaign in assembly elections. Justice Pankaj Mithal dismissed it, while Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah supported it...
Read more'Liquor is available, clean water is not…
22-01-2025
Prime Minister Narendra Modi criticizes the AAP-led Delhi government for failing to provide basic needs like clean water, emphasizing the availability of alcohol instead. Modi urges BJP workers to document...
Read moreSecurity forces neutralise 8 IEDs in Chh…
22-01-2025
The IEDs, planted by Maoists, were discovered during a patrolling operation on the road from Mutvendi to Pidia under Gangalur police station limits., according to Bijapur Police.
Read moreDemand for NRI representation in Parliam…
22-01-2025
Congress MP Deepender Singh Hooda suggested non-resident Indians (NRIs) be given representation in Parliament due to their growing numbers and unique issues. Various organizations and MPs discussed NRI matters, including...
Read moreWatch: Yogi Adityanath leads UP cabinet …
22-01-2025
Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath and the state cabinet participated in a holy dip at Maha Kumbh, while also holding a special cabinet meeting at Sangam. Samajwadi Party leader...
Read more