Attorney General K.K. Venugopal reminded the Supreme Court this week that five judges of the Supreme Court itself had publicly stated that the Supreme Court had failed democracy in the country. “I have nine judges of the Supreme Court saying that there is corruption in the higher judiciary. Two of them made statements while they chaired…seven of them said so immediately after their retirement…,” he added.
But Justice Arun Mishra, due to retire at the end of August, made it clear that in his view it was the court, not democracy, which was threatened and public allegations against judges were undermining the confidence of the people in the judiciary. The bench headed by him, while hearing arguments on the contempt of court case against lawyer Prashant Bhushan that it had taken cognizance of, framed two questions for the court to decide in September.
One, when can public allegations of corruption be made against High Court and Supreme Court judges? And when such allegations are made, what ought to be the procedure adopted by the court.
Even as the debate on ‘corruption’ in the higher judiciary and an allegedly dysfunctional Supreme Court rages, the Ministry of Law and Justice has acknowledged that a staggering number of 534 ‘complaints’ were received by it in just the last two and a half years against High Court and Supreme Court judges since 2018.
In response to an application filed under Right to Information (RTI) Act by Lucknow based advocate and activist Dr Nutan Thakur, the ministry claimed that it routinely forwarded such complaints to the Chief Justices concerned and has no information on the action taken or not taken on such complaints.
While 534 such complaints were received against the judges, it is not clear whether they were from aggrieved litigants and filed after adverse judgments or if they were from lawyers, politicians or from members of the civil society. Nor is it clear how many of such complaints relate to‘corruption’. Prashant Bhushan had argued before the Supreme Court that “Corruption in public life has a wide and expansive definition. Corruption is not restricted to pecuniary gratification alone but various instruments identify its particular forms such as bribery, embezzlement, theft, fraud, extortion, abuse of discretion, favouritism, nepotism, clientelism, conduct creating or exploiting conflicting interests…”
The RTI information reveals that 122 of these complaints were against Supreme Court judges. As many as 52 of them were sent online. Out of the 412 complaints against High Court judges, 164 were sent online. Online complaints leave a digital trail, are easier to track and are less likely to be frivolous.
The ministry also disclosed that the complaints were ‘bulky’ and ran into several pages before hastening to add that it does not retain any of it. A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in 1992 had laid down the procedure to deal with allegations against a sitting judge. The judge had to be given a fair opportunity to be heard before an inquiry committee formed under the Judges Inquiry Act of 1968. The spirit of the 1992 judgment was to “preserve the right, interest and dignity of the judge, which is commensurate with the dignity of all the institutions and functionaries involved in the process”.
Experts have, however, faulted the Supreme Court for not doing enough to clean up not just the process by which judges are appointed but also on the administrative aspects. Justice Venkatramaiah, the 19th Chief Justice of India, had said on the eve of his retirement, “The judiciary has deteriorated in its standards because such judges are appointed as are willing to be ‘influenced by lavish parties and whisky bottles’.”Nor has the judiciary been able to stop the sons and sons-in-law of sitting judges from practicing in the same court or the same city
World's most expensive Indo-US NISAR sat…
23-12-2024
Nasa announced that NISAR, the advanced earth observation satellite developed by India and the US, is set to launch in March 2025. With dual-frequency radar, NISAR will monitor planetary changes...
Read moreCongress always insulted Ambedkar, now c…
23-12-2024
BJP alleges Congress disrespected B R Ambedkar during his lifetime by ignoring his contributions and not awarding him with Bharat Ratna or Padma awards. BJP leader Ravi Shankar Prasad demands...
Read moreRSS chief Mohan Bhagwat’s mandir-masjid …
23-12-2024
Akhil Bharatiya Sant Samiti has criticised RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat's remarks cautioning against temple-mosque disputes, emphasizing that such religious matters should be decided by religious leaders. This dissent highlights ongoing...
Read moreAmit Shah eyes intel synergy with 'frien…
23-12-2024
Union Home Minister Amit Shah emphasizes cooperation with friendly nations on intelligence to detect anti-India outfits. He highlights the importance of new strategies to counter emerging threats, including cyber and...
Read more2022 Agnipath protest: 69 people from Al…
23-12-2024
A claims tribunal in Meerut has ordered 69 individuals to pay over Rs 12 lakh for damaging public property during protests against the Agnipath scheme in 2022. The protests saw...
Read moreParliament panel to hold first meet on o…
23-12-2024
A Joint Parliamentary Committee's first meeting on 'one nation, one election' is set for Jan 8, with an agenda to assess the implications of simultaneous Lok Sabha and state assembly...
Read more'Benegal told raw & real stories abo…
23-12-2024
The film fraternity mourned the passing of Shyam Benegal, a pioneer of New Wave cinema, who mentored numerous actors and revolutionized Indian cinema with films like 'Ankur' and 'Manthan'. His...
Read moreShyam Benegal: The man who talent-spotte…
23-12-2024
Shyam Benegal, starting from scratch in cinema, discovered talents like Naseeruddin Shah, Shabana Azmi, and Smita Patil in the '70s art film movement. Naseeruddin Shah got noticed despite his unconventional...
Read morePharma company hauled up for taking doct…
23-12-2024
Pharma department has reprimanded AbbVie Healthcare for sending 30 doctors to Paris and Monaco, spending over Rs 1.9 crore, violating uniform travel and hospitality guidelines. The National Medical Commission has...
Read moreA junoon without parallel: Shyam Benegal…
23-12-2024
Shyam Benegal, a pioneering filmmaker in India's parallel cinema movement, passed away days after his 90th birthday. His debut film 'Ankur' marked the beginning of a new wave in Hindi...
Read moreSaved after suicide bid, man gets death …
23-12-2024
Pramathes Ghosal, a private tutor from Bengal's Hooghly district, was sentenced to death for the brutal triple murder of his elderly parents and married sister in November 2021. He claimed...
Read more500 years on, Vasco da Gama hailed in Li…
23-12-2024
History appears to be overlooked at St Francis Church in Fort Kochi, with no events marking 500 years since Vasco da Gama's death. Post-colonial perspectives often view da Gama negatively...
Read moreDelhi HC denies anticipatory bail to for…
23-12-2024
Delhi high court denied anticipatory bail to former IAS probationer Puja Khedkar, citing a strong prima facie case of cheating and forgery to wrongfully avail OBC and disability quota benefits...
Read morePunjab beefs up security at thanas, post…
23-12-2024
Punjab Police have heightened security measures following recent terrorist attacks in Amritsar and Gurdaspur. Nets have been strategically placed on rooftops and boundary walls of police establishments to mitigate bomb...
Read moreFamilies raise doubts over encounter of …
23-12-2024
Punjab and Uttar Pradesh police conducted a joint operation, resulting in the deaths of three alleged Khalistan Zindabad Force operatives. The men's families contested the encounter, questioning their involvement and...
Read more