In an open letter addressed to the judges of the Supreme Court of India, a copy of which was emailed on Thursday, August 20, Ashis Ray, London based journalist (disclaimer: he is a regular contributor to the National Herald) has urged the court not to betray the people of India at a critical moment of its history.
“Decent, right-thinking, well-meaning Indians have looked up to the Supreme Court as a benevolent arbiter. When all else fails, the Supreme Court will rescue us, is the refrain. What are such people thinking today? Few worse calamities can befall India than Indians losing confidence in the Supreme Court,” he wrote.
The full text of the letter can be read here:
Dear Honourable Justices,
I don't know how many there are like me among India's 1.35 billion plus citizens, for I was born in Vienna, have lived two-thirds of my life in London, but have always been an Indian national.
It perhaps reflects my humble commitment and loyalty to India. It does not matter that India hasn't recognised this, since my dedication to my country is not for any kudos.
However, it does concern me when India strays from its prescribed path. I was distraught when Charan Singh was sworn in as prime minister and never proved his majority in parliament. And I was very worried when Narendra Modi was elected. Indeed, my worst fears in this respect have come true.
*The highest number of new COVID19 cases per day in the world is being recorded in India. Goodness knows where the death toll will reach. An unscientific response is responsible for this.
*At least 120 million in the informal sector and 20 million in organised industries are unemployed. If such people are the main breadwinners in their families, then 700 million Indians are in serious distress. This catastrophe is caused by the Indian economy being progressively in decline for the greater part of the last six years, despite tailwinds, and no stimulus worth its salt is being offered. India is bankrupt. Its sovereign rating is just above junk.
*All credible reports point to Chinese troops still occupying parts of Indian territory in Ladakh. This indicates a gross failure of our foreign policy in the past six years, which has even ruined India's historical special relationship with Nepal, let alone ties with others. India is almost without a dependable ally among its neighbours. Its biggest defence supplier and traditional friend-in-need Russia is sitting on the fence.
*Kashmiris in Kashmir are Indian citizens. Yet, the worst human rights abuse has been heaped on them by the Indian state. The devastation to its economy is incalculable. Alienation in the Valley is unprecedented.
In all of the above the Supreme Court of India has bafflingly either been silent or not deemed it urgent enough to take up the matter and pronounce judgement.
On the prima facie instance of violation of the Prevention of Corruption Act in the dumping of the previous deal to purchase Rafale aircraft from France and its replacement by a new one, the Supreme Court provided a clean chit.
At the same time, you have taken umbrage at advocate Prashant Bhushan's tweets as if the heavens would fall if you didn't. Is his anguish not legitimate given the prevailing state of affairs?
Sometimes the most vicious and vile reactions arise in respect of the conduct of the Supreme Court in the United Kingdom, including offensive headlines in the tabloid press. Judges have even been described as being anti-British. Not once, though, has the court bothered to lend importance to such tripe.
Decent, right-thinking, well-meaning Indians have looked up to the Supreme Court as a benevolent arbiter. When all else fails, the Supreme Court will rescue us, is the refrain.
What are such people thinking today? Few worse calamities can befall India than Indians losing confidence in the Supreme Court.
Therefore, I appeal to your conscience. I am older than all of you. Please listen to me. I speak from having been fortunate enough to encounter rich and rewarding experiences in life.
India is paramount. I plead before you not to let India down.
I hope you will excuse this intervention.
Faithfully,
Ashis Ray
London
India remains committed to people-centri…
04-04-2025
Prime Minister Narendra Modi met Muhammad Yunus, chief adviser of Bangladesh's interim government, at the Bimstec Summit in Bangkok. Modi raised concerns over minority safety in Bangladesh and urged a...
Read moreIndia-EU FTA: 'Hopeful deal will be fina…
04-04-2025
India is optimistic about finalizing the free trade agreement with the European Union by the end of this year. Comprehensive negotiations led by Prime Minister Modi and European Commission President...
Read more'I am not in Tamil Nadu party leadership…
04-04-2025
Tamil Nadu BJP president K Annamalai stated on Friday that the party's leader would be chosen unanimously, and clarified that he is not a contender. This announcement follows speculation about...
Read more'Congress demanding clarity from Centre …
04-04-2025
Congress leaders, including Shashi Tharoor and Rahul Gandhi, have demanded clarity from the Indian government regarding its strategy for addressing the recent 26 percent reciprocal tariffs imposed by the US...
Read more'PM should come give answer in House,' s…
04-04-2025
Amid Opposition uproar, Congress MP Amarinder Singh Raja Warring has demanded that Prime Minister Narendra Modi address the issue of the U.S. imposing 26% reciprocal tariffs on Indian goods in...
Read more'Rise in incidents of Hindu temples bein…
04-04-2025
The Ministry of External Affairs has expressed serious concerns over the increasing incidents of anti-India graffiti defacing Hindu temples in the US. Diplomatic channels are actively addressing these hate crimes...
Read moreWaqf Bill sparks rift within JD(U) as fi…
04-04-2025
Not one or two but at least five leaders submitted their resignations as the bill was passed, first in Lok Sabha and then the Rajya Sabha on Thursday and Friday...
Read moreCongress launches Manmohan Singh fellows…
04-04-2025
The Congress launched a fellowship program named after former PM Manmohan Singh, selecting 50 mid-career professionals annually for mentorship by senior party leaders. This full-time commitment focuses on building a...
Read more'Extremely unfortunate': LS Speaker Om B…
04-04-2025
Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla criticised Sonia Gandhi's comments on the Waqf Amendment Bill, calling them "unfortunate" and undermining parliamentary democracy. Despite extensive discussions and proper procedures, Birla noted her...
Read more'Will continue to resist all assaults of…
03-04-2025
Congress leader Jairam Ramesh announced the party's intent to challenge the constitutionality of the Waqf (Amendment) Bill in the Supreme Court following its passage in both houses of Parliament. The...
Read moreWatch: PM Modi shares highlights from 'a…
03-04-2025
Prime Minister Narendra Modi attended the sixth Bimstec Summit in Bangkok, where he discussed key areas of cooperation with Thai Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra. Modi also attended cultural events, highlighting...