The Supreme Court on Tuesday reserved its verdict on the sentence to be imposed on advocate Prashant Bhushan in the contempt case filed against him for his tweets criticising the judiciary, legal news website BarandBench.com reported.
The order was reserved by a Bench of Justices Arun Mishra, BR Gavai and Krishna Murari, who heard Senior Advocate Rajeev Dhavan and Attorney General for India KK Venugopal at length.
Dhavan, appearing for Bhushan, informed the court that his client had submitted a statement clarifying his stance yesterday.Bhushan had filed a supplementary statement reiterating his position to stand by his tweets. He refused to apologise for the tweets for which he was held to be in contempt for. His statement says, "If I retract a statement before this court that I otherwise believe to be true or offer an insincere apology, that in my eyes would amount to the contempt of my conscience and of an institution that I hold in highest esteem."
The court then sought the views of Attorney General KK Venugopal on how to proceed with the matter. The AG responded, "He (Bhushan) may be given a warning first and let go. He need not be punished."Justice Mishra then said, "But he doesn't think whatever he did was wrong. He did not submit an apology...What to do when someone does not think they did something wrong?"
The AG then reminded the Bench of the time he had proceeded against Bhushan in connection with the Rafale case."He (Bhushan) expressed regret and then when I read it, I thought we should not proceed with contempt and I withdrew the same because he expressed regret...it will be a great service if Your Lordships take a compassionate view and leave it there," he said.
Justice Mishra went on to say, "When Mr. Bhushan does not think he did anything wrong then what is the point of giving him advice to not repeat it?"
When the AG pointed out the good work Bhushan has done by filing PILs before the Court, Justice Gavai remarked, "PILs and all is good work but when it came to you, even you filed a contempt......You withdrew it only after he expressed regret. But that's not the case here."
Justice Mishra added, "There are very serious statements made. They are asking us to consider his defence during sentencing...He has made so many remarks. Even in the Ramjanmabhoomi case...Only one of those judges has retired."
When Venugopal said that Bhushan would not do it again, the court replied, "Let him say that. But he then instead of that he gave colour to those tweets."
Venugopal then suggested that Bhushan's response be taken off record. However, Justice Mishra said, "Everyone is criticizing us that we have not considered his response and the AG is saying take his response off the record... Now if this is removed, we will be blamed that we removed his response on our own."
The Bench went on to refer to a statement made by Bhushan saying that the "Supreme Court has collapsed"."Isn't that objectionable?" asked Justice Mishra.Referring to the various allegations made by Bhushan in his filings, Justice Mishra said, "Which judge is left out, sitting or retired?" The Court then broke for lunch.
Waqf case: Court extends AAP's Amanatull…
05-11-2024
A Delhi court extended AAP MLA Amanatullah Khan's judicial custody till November 16 in the Delhi Waqf Board money laundering case. The Enforcement Directorate (ED) claimed Khan might hamper the...
Read moreJ&K: Terrorists open fire on securit…
05-11-2024
Security forces in Jammu and Kashmir's Bandipora district engaged in a fierce firefight with terrorists hiding in the forest area. Acting on credible intelligence, the forces launched a search operation...
Read moreYogi Adityanath targets JMM's 'corruptio…
05-11-2024
Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath fiercely criticized the ruling JMM-led coalition in Jharkhand, alleging corruption and mafia involvement. He urged voters to elect the BJP for a crackdown on...
Read more'Protocol wasn't followed, will take act…
05-11-2024
Jharkhand's chief electoral officer is demanding an explanation from Ranchi Airport after Hemant Soren's helicopter was delayed for 90 minutes. The delay was attributed to security protocols for PM Modi...
Read moreJharkhand illegal mining scam: CBI condu…
05-11-2024
The CBI conducted searches at 16 locations across three states. The searches were related to an illegal stone mining scam in Jharkhand. The scam involves Pankaj Mishra, an alleged political...
Read moreLDF, UDF engaging in 'appeasement politi…
05-11-2024
The BJP has accused Kerala's ruling LDF and opposition UDF of engaging in "appeasement politics" by opposing the Centre's proposed amendments to the Waqf law. Javadekar criticized both parties for...
Read more'BJP only indulges in loot': Kharge blas…
05-11-2024
Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge heavily criticized Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the BJP at a Jharkhand election rally. Kharge accused the BJP of prioritizing wealth over citizen welfare and failing...
Read moreWinter session of Parliament to be held …
05-11-2024
India's parliament will convene for the winter session from November 25 to December 20. The session will address important legislation. A special joint sitting will commemorate the 75th anniversary...
Read moreTemple idols found desecrated in Hyderab…
05-11-2024
Five Navagraha idols were found vandalized at a Hanuman temple in Shamshabad, Hyderabad, prompting protests from locals. Police detained a suspect and are reviewing CCTV footage. The BJP condemned the...
Read more'What happened in Canada is a serious ma…
05-11-2024
Indian political leaders across party lines have strongly condemned the recent attack on a Hindu temple in Canada. They called upon the Canadian government to ensure the safety and security...
Read more'I should stop somewhere': Sharad Pawar …
05-11-2024
Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) chief Sharad Pawar has signaled his intention to retire from electoral politics after his Rajya Sabha term concludes in 2026. Pawar stated that he would...
Read more‘When did I threaten him?’ HD Kumaraswam…
05-11-2024
M Chandrasekhar, head of the Lokayukta Special Investigation Team (SIT), filed a complaint alleging threats from former Karnataka chief minister HD Kumaraswamy and his son, Nikhil Kumaraswamy. The threats allegedly...
Read more'His approach was forgotten': Omar Abdul…
05-11-2024
Jammu and Kashmir chief minister Omar Abdullah stated that the current situation in the region could have been avoided if the BJP government had adopted former Prime Minister Atal Bihari...
Read more'Disengagement chapter done, de-escalati…
05-11-2024
India and China have completed troop disengagement along contested border areas, marking the end of their latest standoff. External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar announced the development, stating that both nations...
Read more'Constitution allows minorities to build…
05-11-2024
The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of the Uttar Pradesh Madrasa Education Act 2004, overturning a previous Allahabad High Court decision. While affirming the right of minorities to establish...
Read more'Alamgir Alam looted Jharkhand people': …
05-11-2024
At a Koderma election rally, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath criticized the JMM government, likening a leader to Mughal emperor Aurangzeb for alleged corruption. He urged voters to elect...
Read moreState can't seize all private property f…
05-11-2024
In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court ruled that states cannot seize private property for redistribution, overturning a previous socialist-leaning judgment. The 7:2 ruling clarified that while states can acquire...
Read more'Doesn't violate principle of secularism…
04-11-2024
The Supreme Court overturned a high court ruling, upholding the Uttar Pradesh Madrassa Education Act. The court affirmed the state's right to regulate educational standards in madrassas without infringing...
Read more